Chloe Cole was twelve years old when she first expressed signs of gender dysphoria. She was soon placed on puberty blockers and testosterone. At age fifteen, she had a double mastectomy. Only a year later, Chloe regretted this irreversible procedure and began to detransition. Although her thoughts about gender dysphoria have changed, her body has not. Chloe now lives with painful side effects from so-called “gender-affirming care.”
Gender dysphoria has recently become a prevalent and controversial issue in culture. Children struggling with gender dysphoria are often told to medically transition to the opposite gender in order to resolve their distress and protect their mental health. This raises an important question for Christians: “How does Jesus want us to respond to gender dysphoria?”
In Matthew 22:37-39, Jesus says the greatest commandment is to love God. The second commandment is like it: “Love your neighbor as yourself.” These verses serve as a guidepost for navigating complex issues in culture. A Christian response should first honor the Lord, and second, promote greater human flourishing in society.
The Bible teaches in Genesis 1:27 that God created male and female in His own image. A few verses later, Genesis 1:31 says God “saw all that He had made, and it was very good.” These verses affirm that the human body is much more than mere matter.
Each person is intentionally designed by a sovereign and perfect Creator for a great purpose. Therefore, no one is born as the wrong sex or has a faulty design.
Christian theology values the body much more than secularism, which ultimately reduces each person to just matter. According to the secular view, the body is not intrinsically good nor reflective of a perfect Being. This perspective allows children to hate the body they were born in. While secularism sees the physical body as flawed, it views the mind, such as a person’s thoughts and emotions, as infallible.
Each person is intentionally designed by a sovereign and perfect Creator for a great purpose. No one is born as the wrong sex or has a faulty design.
This view conforms the body to match the mind’s thoughts. As a result, secularists encourage children to physically change their bodies through puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries to align with their feelings of gender dysphoria. By doing so, secularists absolutize the mind over matter.
The Bible teaches the opposite. Jeremiah 17:9 warns the “heart is deceitful above all things.” Scripture teaches that the mind is fallible, while the human body is a flawless creation of God. The mind should be changed to align with the body, not the other way around.
There is still widespread consensus in society that the mind can lead the body down dangerous paths. For instance, many young women struggle with their body image. Some women go to drastic measures to change their bodies and sadly develop eating disorders. Society does not affirm or celebrate the woman’s eating disorder because it recognizes that it can have disastrous effects on her well-being. It is the woman’s mind that needs to be changed, not her body.
There are many other dangerous thoughts the mind can fixate on, such as lust, depression, and self-harm. Conforming the body to such thoughts would bring terrible destruction to society. While many people recognize the danger of conforming the body to the mind in these examples, they fail to acknowledge that transgenderism stems from the same philosophy.
Christians know that the only perfect mind is the mind of Christ. Because He is both omniscient and good, His view of the body can be trusted. The most loving response to children struggling with gender dysphoria is not to help them change their bodies to align with their harmful thoughts but to help them change their minds to align with the perfect mind of Christ.
Emily Huseman holds an M.A. in Christian Apologetics and is currently pursuing a Ph.D. in Public Policy at Liberty University. She is passionate about addressing cultural issues through the lens of a biblical worldview, and her winning essay is a powerful testament to the impact of thoughtful, Christ-centered engagement in today’s society.